Libby swam in seven events, including all five relays, and earned All-America honors in all three freestyle relays at the NCAA Division III Swimming & Diving Championships at the IU Natatorium in Indianapolis. He anchored the 200- and 400-freestyle squads that placed seventh to earn first-team All-America recognition as well as the 800-freestyle team that took 11th to garner honorable mention. All three freestyle relays also reset their own school and Centennial Conference records. Libby also swam the butterfly leg of both the 200- and 400-medley relay teams that each placed 17th to miss All-America status by one spot. In addition, he placed 20th in the 200-freestyle and 21st in the 100-freestyle as Gettysburg finished with 60 points to place 14th among 52 teams that scored a point.